Evaluation Criteria Final Draft:

Includes a snappy title that catches the reader’s attention and indicates the topic and argument.
Identifies an arguable/contestable issue appropriate to the assignment and
Presents the issue in question form,
Provides well-developed reasons about your relationship to the issue:
why you this issue is compelling to you,
what you already know about this issue,
what you need to learn and how you will find this information, and
who is interested in this argument
Answers the “so what” and “who cares” question by explaining why the research topic is significant and to whom.
Supports reasons with thoughtful, well-developed examples anecdotes, ideas, and questions.
Comes across as a credible writer, and appeals to the values and emotions of the audience.
Develops a seamless, coherent, and well-organized argument.
Sentences are lively, engaging, and relatively error free.
If outside sources are used, they are used effectively and integrated smoothly to help substantiate or support points.
If outside sources are used, there is proper attribution to each source cited via in-text parenthetical citation and a correctly formatted Works Cited page.
Write 750-1000 words in MLA Style in 12pt. Times New Roman font. Submissions that do adhere to the minimum writing requirement are very unlikely to earn a passing score.

Additionally, avoid choosing “popular” topics that have been overdone. These topics tend to be too broad (they are not yet issues), too simplistic (for/against), and/or have been written about so many times that it is challenging for students to formulate a new and original response to the issue. When choosing a topic, avoid arguments, such as abortion or gun control, that have created long-standing debates with little resolution between the opposing sides, unless there is recent legislation or proposed legislation that has created a new controversy about the issue. Also, avoid arguments about religion or topics that try to persuade based on religious preferences.

Topics to avoid:

Abortion
Capital Punishment / Death Penalty
Legalization of Marijuana
Gun Control
Immigration
Legal Drinking Age
Impact of Technology and/or Social Media
Euthanasia / Assisted Suicide
Global Warming
Same-sex marriage
Vaccination / Immunization
Animal testing