•The structure is clearly organized and appropriate.•The analysis includes a strong thesis statement; all ideas are related to the thesis.•Ideas are in logical order and connected with 5 or more meaningful transitions.•The development of ideas is effective, with credible and compelling analysis.•The analysis includes 5 or more relevant textual evidence that support thesis statement.•The analysis contains thoughtful and engaging content; it demonstrates thorough understanding of the text.•Word choice is precise and appropriate.•Sentences are strong and varied.•Command of spelling, punctuation, grammar, and usage conventions is strong.